Santa Clara University
Religious Studies Department, SCU
Class Prep
Course Links
Style Sheet
Bible
 
Protestant Apocalypticism and Israel in Christian End-Time Scripts
 
Jerry Falwell Speaks to Reporters (AP)
The readings for today range over a broad swath of "Christian" apocalyptic thought, from mainstream Protestantism (Moorhead) to evangelical Protestantism and finally to the radical, anti-Semitic and anti-NWO fringe (Daniels, Barkun).   As you read these materials, look for the operative apocalyptic script of the end-time and for the ways it has developed beyond the New Testament texts we read in our last class.
 
It is probably best to begin with the "mainstream" and move to the fringe.  Therefore, begin with Moorhead, and from his encyclopedia article be able to answer the following questions:
 
  1. What are postmillennialism and premillennialism?  How is postmillennialism associated with the theory of human progress born in the Enlightenment?   How is it associated with the great revivals of the nineteenth century?

  2. How was America's role in salvation history perceived among progressivist millenarians?  How did the progressivists deal with the biblical prophecies of a period of tribulation or turmoil?

  3. What social movements were affected by Protestant millennialism, and how were they affected?

  4. What specific challenges did the emergence of higher criticism pose to Protestant readings of Daniel and Revelation?  How did mainstream Protestantism respond, and how was this tied to an emerging consumerist ethos and to biological evolution?

  5. For premillennialists, what is at stake in the assertion that Christ's return will precipitate the millennium?  That is, what social and religious positions do they refute?
 
Now read the Barkun essay about Politics and Apocalypticism.  Barkun argues that there are currently three styles of millenarian expression, the traditional, the secular and the improvisational.  Know the characteristics of each.  In addition, consider the following questions:
 
  1. What different adaptations have apocalyptic activists made since the 1970s?  Correlate Baptist minister Jerry Falwell's infamous remarks after 9-11 to Barkun's analysis.1

  2. In secular apocalyptic scenarios, who is the enemy?

  3. The improvisational forms of millenarian expression include groups that use "apocalyptic bricolage" and "stigmatized knowledge."  Identify these terms.  In this section of Barkun's essay, you will read about the Protocols of the Elders of Zion; read the Daniels reading, pp. 93-107, for excerpts and discussion of that text.  Barkun also discusses Christian Identity groups, their "scriptures," The Turner Diaries, and anxieties about the New World Order.  Daniels provides some primary materials on these topics on pp. 108-125.

  4. How is the NWO a rallying point for traditional, secular and improvisational millenarians?
 
Finally, Mark Juergensmeyer offers us a little more background on the Christian Identity group, whom Barkun classifies as one of the improvisational millenarian groups.  How is a utopian Israel constructed in these circles?  In class, we will contrast this construction to the role of the State of Israel in U.S. evangelical Christianity (on the latter, you might take a look at Donald Wagner's short online piece, "Evangelicals and Israel: Theological Roots of a Political Alliance," Christian Century [4 November 1998] 1020-1026).
 
 
Assigned Readings
Primary: Daniels 93-125
Secondary: Moorhead, "Apocalypticism in Mainstream Protestantism, 1800 to the Present"; Barkun, "Politics and Apocalypticism" (both on ERes); Juergensmeyer 30-36
Optional: Katz and Popkin, "From British Israel to Christian Identity and Aryan Nation"; Harding, "Imagining the Last Days: The Politics of Apocalyptic Language"; Shepperson, "The Comparative Study of Millenarian Movements (ERes)
 
 
Further Reading
 
See also the section of the Course Bibliography on Jerusalem and Israel in Contemporary Jewish, Christian and Muslim Eschatologies.
 
 
Links
 
 
Sources
Photograph: AP Photo, Bob Simon, "Falwell Brands Mohammed a 'Terrorist,'" CBSNews.com, 60 Minutes, 6 October 2002, online, http://www.cbsnews.com/
stories/ 2002/10/03/60minutes/main524268.shtml, 27 October 2002.
 

1 "Transcript of Pat Robertson's Interview with Jerry Falwell, 13 September 2001," People for the American Way, Online, http://www.pfaw.org/issues/right/robertson_falwell.html, 19 August 2002  For Falwell's and Robertson's retractions, see Pat Robertson, "Pat Robertson Addresses Comments Made by Jerry Falwell, PatRobertson.com, 17 September 2001, Online, http://www.patrobertson.com/ PressReleases/falwell.as, 18 August 2002.
Get Adobe Acrobat